1 Samuel 4:1-11

1 Samuel 4:1-11

[1] And the word  of Samuel  came to all Israel.  went out  the Philistines  to battle,  and pitched  beside Ebenezer:  and the Philistines  pitched  in Aphek.  [2] And the Philistines  put themselves in array  Israel:  and when they joined  battle,  Israel  was smitten  before  the Philistines:  and they slew  of the army  in the field  about four  thousand  men.  [3] And when the people  were come  into the camp,  the elders  of Israel  said,  Wherefore hath the LORD  smitten  us to day  before  the Philistines?  Let us fetch  the ark  of the covenant  of the LORD  out of Shiloh  unto us, that, when it cometh  among  us, it may save  us out of the hand  of our enemies.  [4] So the people  sent  to Shiloh,  that they might bring  from thence the ark  of the covenant  of hosts,  which dwelleth  between the cherubims:  and the two  sons  of Eli,  Hophni  and Phinehas,  were there with the ark  of the covenant  of God.  [5] And when the ark  of the covenant  of the LORD  came  into the camp,  all Israel  shouted  with a great  shout,  so that the earth  rang again.  [6] And when the Philistines  heard  the noise  of the shout,  they said,  What meaneth the noise  of this great  shout  in the camp  of the Hebrews?  And they understood  that the ark  of the LORD  was come  into the camp.  [7] And the Philistines  were afraid,  for they said,  God  is come  into the camp.  And they said,  Woe  unto us! for there hath not been such a thing heretofore.  [8] Woe  unto us! who shall deliver  us out of the hand  of these mighty  Gods?  that smote  the Egyptians  with all the plagues  in the wilderness.  [9] Be strong,  and quit  O ye Philistines,  that ye be not servants  unto the Hebrews,  as they have been  to you: quit  and fight.  [10] And the Philistines  fought,  and Israel  was smitten,  and they fled  every man  into his tent:  and there was a very  great  slaughter;  for there fell  of Israel  thirty  thousand  footmen.  [11] And the ark  of God  was taken;  and the two  sons  of Eli,  Hophni  and Phinehas,  were slain. 

What does 1 Samuel 4:1-11 Mean?

Contextual Meaning

The Philistines, as we have already seen in Judges , were Israel"s primary enemy to the west at this time. Samson, too, fought the Philistines ( Judges 13-16). [1] There are about150 references to the Philistines in1,2Samuel. They originally migrated from Greece primarily by way of Crete (Caphtor, cf. Genesis 10:14; Jeremiah 47:4; Amos 9:7). Their major influx into Canaan occurred about1200 B.C, about100 years before the events recorded in this chapter. However there were some Philistines in Canaan as early as Abraham"s day ( Genesis 21:32; et al.). [2]
The town of Aphek (cf. 1 Samuel 29:1; New Testament Antipatris, Acts 23:31) stood on the border between Philistine and Israelite territory. It was about11miles east and a little north of Joppa (and modern Tel Aviv). Archaeologists have not yet located Ebenezer, but it was obviously close to Aphek and on Israel"s side of the border. It may have been the modern Izbet Sarteh about two miles east of Aphek on the road to Shiloh. [3]
In Israel"s first encounter with the Philistines in1Samuel, the enemy slew4 ,000 Israelite soldiers ( 1 Samuel 4:2), and in the second, 30 ,000 Israelites fell ( 1 Samuel 4:10). Between these two encounters the Israelites sent to Shiloh for the ark. The ark had always been the place where God dwelt in a special way among the Israelites. It contained the tablets of the Decalogue and the mercy seat where the high priest atoned for the sins of the nation. It was for these reasons a symbol of God and His presence. During the long period of the judges the Israelites as a whole had adopted an increasingly pagan attitude toward Yahweh. They felt that they could satisfy Him with simply formal worship and that they could secure His help with offerings rather than humility. They were treating the ark the same way they treated God; they believed the ark"s presence among them in battle would ensure victory.
"We eventually all learn what Israel discovered in battle against the Philistines. Having the paraphernalia of God and having God are not the same." [4]
The paraphernalia that modern believers sometimes rely on in place of God include a crucifix, a picture of Jesus, or a family Bible positioned conspicuously in the home but seldom read. Others base their hope of spiritual success on a spiritually strong spouse, regular church attendance, or even the daily reading of the Bible. These things, as good as they may be, are no substitute for a vital personal relationship with God.
Perhaps the elders of Israel remembered that in Joshua"s conquest of Jericho, the ark played a very important and visible part in the victory ( Joshua 6:2-20). Nevertheless, back then the people trusted in Yahweh, not in the ark as a talisman (good luck charm). The custom of taking idols into battle so their gods would deliver them was common among ancient warriors (cf. 2 Samuel 5:21; 1 Chronicles 14:12). Obviously the Israelites were wrong in thinking that the presence of the ark would guarantee success.
"The offenses against the ark as pledge of Yahweh"s presence appear to be mainly of two kinds: (1) a misplaced reliance on the ark, and (2) an irreverent disregard for the ark." [5]
The Hebrew word eleph, translated thousand ( 1 Samuel 4:2), can also mean military unit. Military units were of varying sizes but considerably smaller than1 ,000 soldiers. [6]
Ancient Near Eastern artists sometimes pictured a king sitting on a throne supported on either side by a cherub, which the artist represented as a winged lion (sphinx) with a human head. [7] This may have been the image of the Lord of hosts (armies) "who sits above the cherubim" that the writer had in mind here ( 1 Samuel 4:4).
The fact that the people shouted loudly when the ark arrived at Ebenezer from Shiloh ( 1 Samuel 4:5) may be another indication that they were hoping to duplicate the victory at Jericho (cf. Joshua 6:20). Likewise the response of the Philistines when they heard the cry recalls Rahab"s revelation of how the Canaanites feared Yahweh ( Joshua 2:9-11). These allusions to the victory at Jericho contrast the Israelites" present attitude toward God with what it had been at that earlier battle.
The fact that the Israelites suffered a devastating slaughter (Heb. makkah, 1 Samuel 4:10), many times worse than their earlier recent defeat ( 1 Samuel 4:2), proved that victory did not come from the ark but from the Lord. Defeat was due to sin in the camp, including Hophni and Phinehas" sin (cf. 1 Samuel 6:12-14). Israel had suffered defeat at Ai about300 years earlier for the same reason: sin among the people ( Joshua 7:11). Trying to duplicate previous spiritual victories by going through the same procedures is no substitute for getting right with God (cf. Judges 16:20; Matthew 23:25).
God did not record the destruction of the tabernacle at Shiloh, but some writers assume the Philistines razed it after they captured the ark. [8] The town probably did suffer destruction then (cf. Jeremiah 7:12; 1 Chronicles 13:5-14; Jeremiah 26:6). [8]6 However, the writer of Chronicles mentioned that the tabernacle still stood in David"s day ( 1 Chronicles 21:29) and when Solomon began to reign ( 2 Chronicles 1:3). The writer of Samuel showed less interest in the sanctuary structure than in the ark. The Philistines may have destroyed the town of Shiloh, but it "revived sufficiently to produce a few worthy citizens in later generations (cf. 1 Kings 11:29; Jeremiah 41:5)." [1]
The Two Tabernacles and the ArkMoses" Tabernacle at:The Ark at:David"s Tabernacle at:Gilgal ( Joshua 5:10; Joshua 10:15; Joshua 10:43)Gilgal ( 1 Samuel 21:1-9)Shiloh ( Joshua 18:1; Joshua 18:9-10)Shiloh ( Joshua 18:10)Bethel ( Judges 20:18-28; Judges 21:1-4)Bethel ( Judges 20:27)Shiloh ( 1 Samuel 1:3)Shiloh ( 1 Samuel 4:3)Ebenezer ( 1 Samuel 4:4-5)Ashdod ( 1 Samuel 5:1)Gath ( 1 Samuel 5:8)Ekron ( 1 Samuel 5:10)Bethshemesh ( 1 Samuel 2:25)Kiriath-jearim ( 1 Samuel 7:1)Mizpah ? ( 1 Samuel 7:9-10)Gilgal ? ( 1 Samuel 10:8; 1 Samuel 13:8-10; 1 Samuel 15:10-15)Nob ( Joshua 6:12; 1 Samuel 22:9-19)Gibeon ( 1 Chronicles 16:39-40; 1 Chronicles 21:29; 1 Kings 3:4; 2 Chronicles 1:3)Perez-uzzah ( 2 Samuel 6:2-11; Jeremiah 7:14)Jerusalem ( 1 Chronicles 15:1)Jerusalem ( 2 Samuel 6:12-17; 1 Chronicles 15:2 to 1 Chronicles 16:6, 1 Chronicles 16:37-38)